Margolis Edelstein



People

Practices

Results

Insights

Offices

Careers

Q

Rolf Kroll Establishes New Law Relating to Transfers of Pendant State Law Claims After the Federal Court Relinquishes Jurisdiction of the Federal Claims

A federal court is not required to retain jurisdiction of pendant state law claims after it has resolved the federal question that vested it with federal jurisdiction in the first place. For more than 30 years, there have been state and federal statutes that govern the transfer of state law claims to state court after the federal claims have been resolved. However, lingering questions remained regarding how long a plaintiff had to transfer their claims and what specific procedures needed to be followed in order to properly transfer them. The federal statute provides, among other things, that the party seeking transfer has a minimum of an additional 30 days to transfer their state law claims without fear that their claims would be time-barred by the statute of limitations. The state law statute provides a simple procedures to be followed to effectuate the transfer and cases interpreting this statute impose a “promptness” requirement but varied significantly on the question of what “promptness” meant in this context.

Against this backdrop, suit was filed against Rolf’s clients for malicious prosecution and false arrest under both state and federal law. After extensive motions practice, Rolf was able to establish that Plaintiff’s liberty was not sufficiently compromised by her arrest to establish a Fourth Amendment seizure thereby warranting dismissal of Plaintiff’s federal claims. However, this left Plaintiff’s state law claims for false arrest and malicious prosecution. These state law claims to not require a Fourth Amendment seizure and accordingly, the federal court relinquished jurisdiction of these claims expressly allowing Plaintiff to transfer them in accordance with the federal transfer statute.

When Plaintiff attempted to transfer her state law claims to state court, Rolf argued they were not timely because they were neither “promptly filed” as required by the state law transfer statute nor were they transferred in compliance with the 30 day grace period provided by the federal transfer statute. Rolf argued that the two transfer statutes should be read in pari materia. The trial court agreed, and the case went on appeal to the Commonwealth Court.

In affirming the opinion of the trial court, the Commonwealth Court agreed with Rolf and in so doing, held for the first time, that the federal and state transfer statutes should be read in pari materia, and that Plaintiff’s failure to follow the state law procedures resulted in a failure to timely effectuate the transfer of Plaintiff’s state law claims to state court. The published Commonwealth Court opinion is available upon request.

Successes & Insights

October 2026 Scotus Term To Resolve Circuit Split On Title Ix Employment Discrimination Claims

October 2026 Scotus Term To Resolve Circuit Split On Title Ix Employment Discrimination Claims

No results found.