On May 22, 2025, after five days of trial in what was expected to be a three-week legal malpractice case, attorneys Glenn Ricketti and Raphaella Poteau, supported by behind-the-scenes strategic guidance from attorney Jim Kahn, secured a Non-Suit at the close of the plaintiff’s case in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas.
The case stemmed from a 2007 water loss event that escalated into nearly two decades of litigation. Over the course of 18 years, the matter spawned:
- 10 separate lawsuits
- Multiple appeals reaching the Pennsylvania Supreme Court
- Claims of bad faith, breach of contract, and fraud
- Allegations of personal injury due to mold exposure
- Economic damages related to credit impairment and property loss
- A legal malpractice claim asserting attorney negligence in the execution of a general release
Plaintiff sought extensive damages, including $400,000 in alleged replacement living expenses, $100,000 in personal property loss, and the total loss of a waterfront condominium, which was ultimately sold at a Sheriff’s sale.
Despite a case filled with complex expert testimony, forensic handwriting analysis, and wide-ranging damage claims, the plaintiff failed to establish a critical element: the “case within a case.” Without proving that any alleged legal malpractice caused actual harm, the court granted our team’s Motion for Non-Suit, ending the trial in favor of our clients.




