Margolis Edelstein



People

Practices

Results

Insights

Offices

Careers

Q

Non-Suit Granted in Philadelphia Legal Malpractice Trial, Ending 18 Years of Litigation

On May 22, 2025, after five days of trial in what was expected to be a three-week legal malpractice case, attorneys Glenn Ricketti and Raphaella Poteau, supported by behind-the-scenes strategic guidance from attorney Jim Kahn, secured a Non-Suit at the close of the plaintiff’s case in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas.

The case stemmed from a 2007 water loss event that escalated into nearly two decades of litigation. Over the course of 18 years, the matter spawned:

  • 10 separate lawsuits
  • Multiple appeals reaching the Pennsylvania Supreme Court
  • Claims of bad faith, breach of contract, and fraud
  • Allegations of personal injury due to mold exposure
  • Economic damages related to credit impairment and property loss
  • A legal malpractice claim asserting attorney negligence in the execution of a general release

Plaintiff sought extensive damages, including $400,000 in alleged replacement living expenses, $100,000 in personal property loss, and the total loss of a waterfront condominium, which was ultimately sold at a Sheriff’s sale.

Despite a case filled with complex expert testimony, forensic handwriting analysis, and wide-ranging damage claims, the plaintiff failed to establish a critical element: the “case within a case.” Without proving that any alleged legal malpractice caused actual harm, the court granted our team’s Motion for Non-Suit, ending the trial in favor of our clients.

Successes & Insights

October 2026 Scotus Term To Resolve Circuit Split On Title Ix Employment Discrimination Claims

October 2026 Scotus Term To Resolve Circuit Split On Title Ix Employment Discrimination Claims

No results found.