Berkeley Heights Partner Patrick Lynott successfully secured threshold victory by filing a Motion to Dismiss in lieu of Answer in a personal injury action arising out of a Virginia motor vehicle accident. Plaintiff filed suit in the Superior Court of New Jersey, asserting claims against our client, an HVAC contractor incorporated in Delaware with a principal place of business in Michigan; and our client driver, an individual who lives in North Carolina.
The Motion to Dismiss was premised on a lack of personal jurisdiction argument, asserting that there was an absence of general jurisdiction due to a lack of sufficient New Jersey contacts; and there was an absence of specific jurisdiction due to Plaintiff’s failure to demonstrate that his claims arose out any meaningful contacts with New Jersey. Plaintiff’s counsel vigorously contested the motion on the merits and also sought jurisdictional discovery to develop proofs of New Jersey contacts. Following comprehensive briefing and oral argument before The Honorable Keri Ann Eglentowicz, J.S.C., the Plaintiff’s action was dismissed in its entirety, resulting in a decisive New Jersey win for Margolis Edelstein’s clients at the inception of the defense of the case.



