In a recent Cumberland County premises liability matter, Harrisburg partner Barry Kronthal obtained summary judgment where the plaintiff alleged serious injuries after falling down an interior staircase that lacked handrails. The plaintiff and her spouse asserted negligence and loss‑of‑consortium claims, supported by expert opinions criticizing the staircase’s construction and the absence of handrails and signage. However, during her deposition, the plaintiff acknowledged she had used the stairs many times before and ultimately could not identify what caused her to fall, a critical gap in her proof.
The defense centered its argument on the principle that proximate cause is an essential element of negligence, and Pennsylvania law requires more than a code violation to establish liability. As the litigation record showed, the lack of a handrail—standing alone—could not satisfy the causal requirement, particularly where the plaintiff testified she did not slip, trip, or observe any defect initiating the fall. Expert reports highlighting code deficiencies did not cure this evidentiary failure because none linked the alleged defects to the actual mechanism of the fall.
The court agreed and granted summary judgment, concluding that the plaintiffs failed to establish a prima facie negligence claim. Because the negligence claim was dismissed, the derivative loss‑of‑consortium claim was dismissed as well. This case underscores a consistent theme in Pennsylvania premises liability law: without evidence of what caused the fall, claims cannot proceed—regardless of alleged defects or code issues.




