Scranton partner Jeffrey Havran successfully defended an insurance carrier in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. The case involved a claim of bad faith against the insurer following the denial of life insurance benefits.
The plaintiff alleged bad faith after the insurer denied a claim during the policy’s contestable period, citing misrepresentation of the plaintiff’s medical history on the application. Jeffrey filed a Motion to Dismiss both the original and amended complaints. The Court determined that the plaintiff failed to establish bad faith, finding no evidence that the insurer recklessly disregarded a reasonable basis for denying benefits.
The Court dismissed the bad faith claim without leave to amend, citing the implausibility of the plaintiff’s allegations based on submitted exhibits.




