Margolis Edelstein



People

Practices

Results

Insights

Offices

Careers

Q

Third Circuit Expands Scope of Retaliation Claims Under ADA and FMLA, Reduced Bonuses and Raises May Constitute Retaliation

Steidle v. United States Liability Insurance Co., Inc., Third Circuit Court of Appeals, June 24, 2026

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit issued a precedential decision clarifying the scope of actionable retaliation under the ADA and FMLA. In doing so, the Court aligned retaliation standards under those statutes with the broader materially adverse standard established in Burlington Northern.

The case arose from claims by an employee who alleged that his employer retaliated against him following requests for FMLA leave and workplace accommodations by awarding lower-than-expected bonuses and salary increases. The Third Circuit vacated the District Court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of the employer, concluding that the plaintiff had not suffered an “adverse employment action” and failed to establish causation.

The Court addressed whether retaliation claims under the ADA and FMLA should be limited to traditional employment actions affecting compensation or job status or instead governed by the broader standard applied in Title VII cases. The Court adopted the latter approach, holding that an action is materially adverse if it could dissuade a reasonable employee from engaging in protected activity. Applying that standard, the Court rejected a narrow interpretation that would exclude compensation decisions from scrutiny and concluded that reductions in bonuses and salary increases, particularly when closely tied in time to protected activity, may constitute actionable retaliation.

Why This Matters for Claims

  1. Compensation decisions now squarely fall within potential retaliation exposure. Reduced bonuses and merit increases may constitute actionable retaliation if they could deter a reasonable employee from engaging in protected activity.
  2. The Court confirmed that the materially adverse standard applies to ADA and FMLA claims, meaning adverse action is not limited to formal changes in employment status or compensation structure.
  3. Timing remains critical. Close temporal proximity between protected activity and compensation decisions can support causation, while longer gaps may defeat such claims absent additional evidence.

Claims Handling Considerations

1. Early Investigation

  • Identify timing of compensation decisions relative to leave or accommodation requests
  • Gather documentation supporting performance-based compensation determinations
  • Evaluate consistency across similarly situated employees

2. Discovery Risk Areas

  • Internal communications regarding bonus determinations and salary increases
  • Performance reviews tied to compensation decisions
  • Documentation of decision-making processes following protected activity

3. Liability Analysis

  • Whether the employer had contemporaneous, documented justification
  • Whether consistent criteria were applied
  • Whether timing suggests a retaliatory motive

4. Defense Strategy Considerations

  • Emphasize objective, performance-based criteria
  • Demonstrate consistency in practices
  • Address timing and provide non-retaliatory explanations
  • Focus on lack of causation where temporal proximity is weak

Conclusion

The Third Circuit’s decision reframes retaliation analysis under the ADA and FMLA by adopting a broader standard focused on the practical impact of employer actions. Compensation decisions, including discretionary bonuses and raises, are now more likely to be scrutinized as potential adverse actions.

For insurers, employers, and claims professionals, the ruling underscores the need for careful documentation, consistency in compensation practices, and early evaluation of timing and causation when defending retaliation claims.

Download the opinion.

Successes & Insights

October 2026 Scotus Term To Resolve Circuit Split On Title Ix Employment Discrimination Claims

October 2026 Scotus Term To Resolve Circuit Split On Title Ix Employment Discrimination Claims

No results found.