By: Jacob Goldstein and John Nolan, June 12, 2025
Recap of the 2024 Muldrow Decision’s Impact on Employment Discrimination Lawsuits
In 2024, the United States Supreme Court reshaped the standard in employment discrimination claims in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis. As discussed in a previous article, the Court rejected the framework previously established in McDonnell Douglas, under which a plaintiff must show “significant” or “serious” harm to establish an adverse employment action. Instead, under Muldrow, a plaintiff need only show “some harm” related to an identifiable term or condition of employment. This marked a clear lowering of the standard.
We predicted that the Third Circuit would apply the Muldrow standard to all discrimination cases. Since 2024, that prediction has largely come to fruition. In July 2024, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issued a decision in Peifer v. Pennsylvania, remanding a Title VII discrimination action due to the Supreme Court’s decision in Muldrow. The Third Circuit clarified that adverse employment actions no longer require harm that is “serious,” “significant,” or “substantial.” In doing so, it vacated the District Court’s order for summary judgment and remanded for reevaluation under the new standard.
The Most Recent Application of the Muldrow Standard
On May 14, 2025, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals issued a decision in McCrorey v. City of Phila. Although nonprecedential, this recent case signals how the court intends to apply the Muldrow framework.
McCrorey was a supervisor in Philadelphia Police Department’s Narcotics Field Unit from 2014 to 2021, operating in the East Division. In July 2020, Christopher Flacco was appointed the Chief Inspector of the Narcotics Bureau, and almost immediately began making reforms to the narcotics enforcement strategy in Kensington, where McCrorey supervised. At a meeting in September 2020, McCrorey alleged that Flacco told supervisors he did not want “fifty-year-old cops” to act as emergency response units and named three men in their forties as the new supervisors, removing McCrorey’s entire squad from the East Division, but not removing his title and instead transferred him to a new division.
McCrorey then filed an EEOC charge alleging age discrimination and retaliation and later filed suit against the City of Philadelphia. The District Court granted summary judgment in favor of the City, finding that McCrorey failed to prove that his transfer constituted an adverse employment action.
Analysis of the Court’s Opinion
The Third Circuit began its analysis noting that the District Court’s ruling predated Muldrow and applied the McDonnell Douglas standard. The lower court required a showing of “significant” harm, thus concluding that McCrorey had not established a prima facie case of age discrimination. The Third Circuit disagreed, holding that under the now governing Muldrow standard, the harm alleged could qualify as “some harm” affecting the conditions of employment. The court remanded the age discrimination claim for reconsideration under the correct standard.
However, the court declined to apply Muldrow to McCrorey’s retaliation claim. Instead, it applied the McDonnell Douglas burden-shifting framework and affirmed summary judgment on that count, finding no genuine issue of material fact.
Moving Forward
As anticipated, the Third Circuit is applying the Muldrow standard to various employment discrimination claims. We expect continued litigation as courts and litigants adjust to this new legal landscape. For employers and insurers, this means reevaluating litigation strategy and risk assessments in active and pending employment discrimination matters.




