By: Ryan Smith, November 4, 2024
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a pivotal ruling in Ungarean v. CNA Insurance Company, 2024 Pa. LEXIS 1433 (Sep. 26, 2024), addressing COVID-19 shutdown business income losses and resolving conflicting interpretations from the Superior Court. This case reviewed whether government-mandated shutdowns during the COVID-19 pandemic constituted a “physical loss,” thus triggering business interruption coverage under a commercial insurance policy.
Previously, the Pennsylvania Superior Court reached opposing conclusions on the issue in 2022, in MacMiles, LLC v. Erie Insurance Exchange, 286 A.3d 331 (Pa. Super. 2022) and Ungarean v. CNA, 286 A.3d 353 (Pa. Super. 2022).
In MacMiles, the court ruled in favor of the insurer, finding that COVID-19 closures did not meet the policy’s “physical loss or damage” requirement, as the virus did not cause tangible damage to property. This interpretation aligned with similar rulings nationwide, generally denying coverage for COVID-19 business interruption claims.
In contrast, the Ungarean decision from the Superior Court favored the insured, finding that the shutdown orders effectively rendered the insured’s premises unusable, satisfying the policy’s “physical loss” requirement even without visible property damage.
On appeal, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that for coverage to apply, the policy language required physical damage, destruction, or alteration to the property. Since COVID-19 did not physically alter or damage the insured properties, as the insured was permitted to use the properties at will and could even perform emergency procedures from these properties during this time, the court determined that the shutdown-related losses were purely economic and did not qualify for business interruption coverage. This ruling sets a definitive standard in Pennsylvania, clarifying that without physical damage, economic losses from mandated shutdowns do not trigger coverage.




